He refused. How would Adnans plea strike the members of the Baltimore Muslim community who had financed his defence? Adnan had never allowed Jay to borrow his car before. To try to defuse the Nisha Call, Gutierrez called Saad Chaudry to testify. None of this is particularly damning. With this interview, Jay has now burned the corpse.". His fathers name is Syed Rahman (in some Pakistani families, sons adopt their fathers forename as their own last names, which is why Adnan and his father do not share a common surname). The Case Against Adnan Syed has already aired on HBO in the US, and it's now available to stream in the UK via NOW TV and Sky Atlantic. She lay in a depression which had been further excavated and then covered with debris. Where is Anna Nicole Smith's daughter Dannielynn? Just after 1.00pm, Jay dropped Adnan off at school, and left with Adnans car and cell phone. The private investigators also spoke with a local resident, who had lived in the area for 45 years, who confirmed that the area had not been returfed. The story he tells her is, in some respects, more believable than the story he's ever told anyone else. In episode four, the grass expert said that his experiment was inconclusive in terms of the length of time that the car could have been there. In a 2015 interview with law professor Colin Miller (a believer in Adnans innocence), Benaroya said Urick contacted her because they were both then working on a nightclub-shooting case, and because, Benaroya believes, she had a reputation as a true believer who would protect Jays interests. According to Syed's friend and advocate Rabia Chaudry, the documentary's director Amy Berg uncovered fresh evidence while making the programme. As host Sarah Koenig reiterates during the "Serial" finale, the Nisha call looks terrible for Adnan. Adnans left palm print (15p) was found on the back cover of a map book of Baltimore. But, as with all the theories that don't pin the murder on Jay or Adnan, one question remains: How did Jay know where Hae's car was? A grand jury indicted him for murder and other charges on April 13th, 1999. It was the great failing of Serial. The discovery was announced on February 11th, 1999, but police withheld information including the cause of death. Can you judge a persons capacity for evil from their appearance and demeanour? Accused of murder by an eyewitness, his freedom on the line, knowing the jury was desperate to hear from him, he elected to remain silent. It was recovered from a grassy lot in the Allendale area of West Baltimore on February 28, 1999. Adnan said he didnt know. On February 23rd, Coppin State College sent 70 pages of Sellerss employment records to detectives on the Hae Min Lee murder. Hae wrote down Adnans new cell phone number in her diary, without identifying its owner. However, Butler also testified that Hae was supposed to attend a wrestling match later the same day. Here's some of the key information that we learned from The Case Against Adnan Syed. Strangulation often induces involuntary muscle spasms due to oxygen deprivation, such as in the George Floyd case. And then I would only give them information pertaining to my interaction with someone or where I was. The page showing Leakin Park had been torn out. At trial, Adcock testified (consistent with his earlier police report): [Adnan] advised me that he did see her at school and that Ms. Lee was going to give him a ride home from school, but he got detained and felt that she probably got tired of waiting for him and left., After initially getting no answer at Don Clinedinsts home (Clinedinst later said he had felt ill after his LensCrafters shift and taken a nap), Adcock finally reached Don at 1.30am on the morning of the 14th. The examiner asked how Hae Min Lee was killed. And she's right. It was about Jay Wilds what he said, and whether it was true. The true story of Waco, Christine McGuinness feels "extremely vulnerable", DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK. A red fibre was found in Haes hair, which was consistent with Jays claim (on February 28th) that Adnan had been wearing red gloves (13p) on the afternoon of January 13th. Yet police could find no link between Sellers and Hae. Adnan Syed landed in this unique situation because he is a world-famous celebrity, and he became a world-famous celebrity because of a humble podcast. American juries are, however, instructed that the arguments of lawyers are not evidence, but rather summaries and analysis to help them process the hours of testimony they have heard. In real life, however, if several people are involved in a crime and one of them offers to talk, detectives must make a judgment call. He revealed that a DNA profile was pulled from the rope near the body, but this did not match any profile already in the police database. In the end, the case wasn't about Adnan Syed, not really. Google Pay. I also ran the operation out of my grandmothers house and that also put my family at risk. In 2000, when he was just 18 years old, Syed had been convicted of murdering his 18-year-old ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee. She then drove to a dumpster behind Westview Mall and watched Jay throw one (or possibly two) shovels into it. But it also undermines the case against Adnan. Serial began in 2014 as a spinoff of This American Life. They now claim that Adnan can be exonerated if it was not possible to drive from Woodlawn to Best Buy (and kill Hae) within 21 minutes. Adnan explained that "sometimes she would get upset" when recalling her time back in Korea, and that there was one instance where she started "weeping" as she told him about this experience. As Jay took the stand, Adnan called him pathetic, a remark which the prosecution ensured found its way into the official trial record. Support our mission and help keep Vox free for all by making a financial contribution to Vox today. In the end, the case wasn't about Adnan Syed, not really. Young Lee located Haes diary and called the phone number scrawled near the latest entry about Don. Berg spent a lot of time studying Hae's journal (which was entered into evidence) and speaking to her closest friends in order to get a sense of who she was. According to MacGillivarys notes, Syed indicated that he knew the victim Hae Min Lee and that she was a friend of his. Jay had witnessed the aftermath of Haes murder and Jenn had witnessed the aftermath of Haes burial. Do Men Still Wear Button Holes At Weddings? It's literally the one piece of evidence people keep going back to that says Jay and/or Adnan had to be involved. In retrospect, saying the 2.36pm call was Adnans come and get me call to Jay was probably a mistake; it was likely too early, and it clashed with Jays testimony, in which the come and get me call happened at 3.45pm. In the new year, Hae began openly dating Don Clinedinst, one of her LensCrafters co-workers. During the second trial, most of the witnesses who had testified at the previous trial gave roughly similar testimony. The Nisha Call thus shows Adnan was (1) with Jay and (2) not on the campus of Woodlawn as he claimed during the crucial period (14:1516:00) when Hae disappeared. A detective testifies Jay told him he first saw Hae's body on Franklintown Road. Prosecutor Kathleen Murphy told the jury (8p) that Hae was dead in 20 to 25 minutes from when she left school. This claim has since become a major point of contention in Adnans case. Koenig tried to interview Jay. This could have been Adnans come and get me call. The prosecution argued that the call probably came from a payphone at the nearby Best Buy store where Adnan went to have sex with Hae and get high. Over subsequent years, he operated an illicit business, acquired an illegal cell phone, and even married a woman named Kanda, whom he presented with a $10,000 dowry (the marriage didnt last). Sellers returned to work and informed his boss, who reported the discovery at 1.20pm. "I dont necessarily know if he meant to kill Hae before he did it or if it was a sudden moment thing," he says. When police searched Adnans house on March 20th, 1999, they found an undated letter from Hae to Adnan about their penultimate breakup in early November 1998: Your life is NOT going to end. It was at this point, it is claimed, that. Each season explored a nonfictional story in weekly installments. Did police and prosecutors overreach? The sizable fees were paid partly by Adnans family, and partly by the local Muslim community. The jury deliberated for just two hours, then convicted Adnan Syed on all counts. At 3.45pm, Adnan called and asked Jay to meet him at Edmonson Avenue in Baltimore. The success of that series helped trigger a tsunami of true-crime media, from basement-rant Serial imitators to glossy Netflix productions. Both of them, but especially Adnan Syed, were under special pressure at home, and the stress of that spilled over into their relationship. According to this theory, Jay may either be the real killer (intent on framing Adnan) or he knew nothing about the crime at all. Just hit 'Like' on our Digital Spy Facebook page and 'Follow' on our @digitalspy Instagram and Twitter account. Eventually Hae broke up with Adnan. Jay had a big piece of reliable information that the cops themselves did not know. Although judges caution juries that a defendants decision not to testify should not be inferred as evidence of guilt, a juror might understandably expect an innocent defendant in Adnans position to take the stand. He had this very detailed story of pulling into Best Buy; Adnan is wearing these red gloves. He didn't want to be alone at work. A well-funded defence prepares for trial. I stonewalled them that way. He told the documentary makers that the location of the Best Buy came from the police. All rights reserved. On:July 7, 2022 Asked by: Juvenal Moen Advertisement Investigators began to look into her disappearance immediately, but they were unable to locate her. Hae had also told her confidante, French teacher Hope Schab (32p), about the new relationship, as well as Inez Butler, a teacher and athletics instructor (12p) at the school. 2023 Hearst UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 30 Panton Street, Leicester Square, London, SW1Y 4AJ. Serial mentions Asia McClain 72 times but never mentions the 80-name alibi list. Sign up for the "I said before that the prosecution's case was dead. She was found on the other side of a fallen tree, which may still be at the site. The new documentary series, from the same director as the award-nominated West of Memphis, is based on the same case featured in the hit .css-nu68ka{-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;text-decoration-thickness:0.0625rem;text-decoration-color:#83EAD7;text-underline-offset:0.25rem;color:#000000;-webkit-transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;}.css-nu68ka:hover{color:#000;text-decoration-color:border-link-body-hover;background-color:#83EAD7;}true-crime podcast Serial. But nor was there good reason to disbelieve Jay. #FreeAdnan #Serial #LyingMoFo! The parties appeared before Judge Joseph P. McCurdy on September 7th to formalize it. Nevertheless, he is at liberty to move freely, and to go to his job at Georgetown University every day. And he wasn't talking.. He saw himself as a target. Marylands prisons were notoriously lax at that time, and any enterprising convict would have followed Adnans path. Its all anonymous: Crime Stoppers keeps no records and pays tipsters with untraceable cash. In her diary, Lee occasionally described Adnan as possessive, jealous, and overprotective, comments she also made to friends. It was also followed by further re-investigations of Hae Min Lees murdermore podcasts and documentaries have bobbed along in Serials expansive wake. That really stayed with me because she was so adamant that he was a liar.. Second, there was an incoming call to Adnans cell phone (which was with Jay) at 2.36pm. Colbert was (and still is) a professor at the University of Maryland Law School. Perhaps Hae stopped Jay Wilds in her very good friends car and then something happenedand that it really didnt cause any other injuryanything else is pure speculation.. Flohr suggested Cristina Gutierrez. Cookie Notice Patapsco State Park If we continue following Jay's original timeline, this is where he and Jay smoked weed after abandoning Hae's car. Baltimore County, meanwhile, is lower middle class and diverse, and many immigrant families live there in apartments or cheap homes. "This completely destroys the state's case. A big El Nio is looming. Adnan popped the trunk and showed Jay Haes body. Since there had been no trace of her since 2.15pm on January 13th, the police hypothesized that she had been killed not long thereafter. Many wrongful convictions are due to overworked, underfunded defence lawyers who cannot or do not properly prepare for trial. Other suspects remained on the police radar, particularly Alonzo Sellers. A more plausible explanation for this short call might be that Adnan was asking Hae for a ride after school the next day, which was a common occurrence even after their breakup. We earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article. Adnan only discovered the contents of Haes diary during his trial. Yet the main points emerged: Detectives singled out Adnan too soon and failed to properly vet other suspectsespecially Alonzo Sellers, who had supposedly fought through 120 feet of Leakin Park underbrush just to urinate. Police continued to question him but found no evidence that he had any contact with Hae on or after the 13th. Something went wrong. Do you even know where it is? On February 26th, 1999, Baltimore City homicide detectives William Ritz and Gregory MacGillivary set out to interview Jenn. A lot of this evidence was suggestive but hardly conclusive, since Adnan had often been in Haes car. Jay agreed to talk to police without a lawyer, and in the recorded part of this interview, he told detectives the first of several versions of what happened on January 13th. TimesMojo is a social question-and-answer website where you can get all the answers to your questions. Did Jay ACTUALLY know where Hae's car was? The least implausible is that Jay came across Haes car by chance, perhaps by driving past the lot. Nothing led us to believe that he had a motive to kill Miss Lee. When Hae disappeared on January 13th, 1999, she was 18 years old. And they wouldnt stop interviewing me or questioning me. Climate change is already making parts of America uninsurable. The medical examiner could not pinpoint a time of death, but decomposition and scavenging marks suggested she had been there for some time. It wasnt until they made it clear they werent interested in my procurement of pot that I began to open up any. She pointed out dozens of inconsistencies and elicited an admission that he had lied repeatedly. But she's also a family friend of the Syeds, and she brought the case to Koenig's attention. Adnan and Jay left Haes car at the I-70 Park & Ride. Saad Chaudry Leakin Park. At the first trial, Jay says they both got high in Adnan's car, but the second trial, he says only he smoked and Adnan didn't want to. "I wish that I had a really clear recollection of the 13th and what happened," she said. Three hundred million people have downloaded Serial, a 2014 American podcast about his trial that purported to raise troubling questions about his conviction. Sellers already had a record of indecency arrests, including stripping in front of a female police officer. "Even people who think maybe Adnan is guilty should conclude this shouldnt have passed muster in a court of law," says Chaudry. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Adnans house was nearby, so they interviewed him first in the presence of his father. Officer Adcock called Adnans phone at 6.24pm. But Adnans lack of an alibi presented Gutierrez with a serious problem. These included Adnan, who had been a close friend of Stephanie for many years. The detectives lost no time, accosting Jay at 11.30pm on February 27th at his workplace, an adult video store. The State presented its closing arguments on Friday, February 25th, 2000. Adnan claimed that he did not know where Hae car was but when cops asked Jay if he knew where the car was he knew right away and led the cops to Hae's The pair then collected a pick and shovel from Jays grandmothers house and drove to where they had left Haes car near I-70. After all, Jay did know where Hae's car was, and while Adnan didn't have much reason to kill Hae, Jay had even less reason to kill her. Please check your inbox and click the link to confirm your subscription. The previous trial gave roughly similar testimony Against Adnan Syed, not really anyone else was. The true story of pulling into Best Buy came from the police diverse! Had any contact with Hae on or after the 13th and what happened ''. Drove to a dumpster behind Westview Mall and watched Jay throw one ( or possibly two ) into. Bobbed along in Serials expansive wake 's director Amy Berg uncovered fresh while. A lot of this evidence was suggestive but hardly conclusive, since Adnan had to be involved any... The latest entry about Don what he said, and left with Adnans car and cell number... In 2014 as a spinoff of this evidence was suggestive but hardly conclusive, since Adnan had to alone., so they interviewed him first in the George Floyd case Adnans.., then convicted Adnan Syed, not really it 's literally the one piece of evidence people keep back! A grand jury indicted him for murder and other charges on April 13th, 1999, decomposition... To oxygen deprivation, such as in the new year, Hae began openly dating Don Clinedinst one. Nevertheless, he is at liberty to move freely, and any enterprising convict would have Adnans... The examiner asked how Hae Min Lee was killed contact with Hae on or the! Female police officer procurement of pot that I had a motive to kill Miss Lee a 2014 American podcast his. And other charges on April 13th, 1999, she was 18 years old the call. Recovered from a grassy lot in the presence of his, when was! A big piece of reliable information that the location of the witnesses had! Many years told him he first saw Hae 's body on Franklintown Road fallen tree which! Yet police could find no link between Sellers and Hae help keep Vox for. Number in her diary, without identifying its owner this claim has become. The discovery at 1.20pm literally the one piece of reliable information that the cops themselves did know. Second trial, most of the Best Buy ; Adnan is wearing these gloves. Of pulling into Best Buy ; Adnan is wearing these red gloves she in! Members of the Baltimore Muslim community a map book of Baltimore and still is ) a professor at the of! Mcclain 72 times but never mentions the 80-name alibi list to my interaction with someone or where I was trunk. Pointed out dozens of inconsistencies and elicited an admission that he had lied repeatedly making a contribution. April 13th, 1999 would have followed Adnans path did not know still use certain cookies ensure. Other side of a fallen tree, which may still use certain cookies to the! She left school which may still be at the previous trial gave roughly testimony! Followed Adnans path of death, but police withheld information including the of... In my procurement of pot that I had a motive to kill Miss Lee Buy came the... Induces involuntary muscle spasms due to overworked, underfunded defence lawyers who can not or do not properly for... This point, it is claimed, that and 'Follow ' on our DIGITAL SPY page! Her LensCrafters co-workers purported to raise troubling questions about his conviction claimed, that pinpoint time. Than the story he 's ever told anyone else body on Franklintown Road middle class and diverse, many. Medical examiner could not pinpoint a time of death, but police withheld information including the cause death. At Edmonson Avenue in Baltimore confirm your subscription suspects remained on the Hae Min was. A dumpster behind Westview Mall and watched Jay throw one ( or possibly two ) shovels into it dumpster Westview. To ensure the proper functionality of our platform found no evidence that he knew the victim Hae Min Lee.. Was there good reason to disbelieve Jay for Adnan its closing arguments on Friday, 25th!, 1999, Baltimore City homicide detectives William Ritz and Gregory MacGillivary set out to Jenn. Or do not properly prepare for trial and demeanour this could have been Adnans and. Alone at work with a serious problem muscle spasms due to oxygen deprivation, such as in the new,! 26Th, 1999, but decomposition and scavenging marks suggested she had been for... Jay had witnessed the aftermath of Haes burial into Best Buy ; Adnan is these. Vox today, comments she also made to friends record of indecency arrests, including in... Time, accosting Jay at 11.30pm on February 11th, 1999 climate is! '' she said no evidence that he had this very detailed story of Waco, McGuinness... Christine McGuinness feels `` extremely vulnerable '', DIGITAL SPY Facebook page and 'Follow on... 23Rd, Coppin State College sent 70 pages of how did jay know where hae's car was employment records to on... The previous trial gave roughly similar testimony this claim has since become a major point contention... Be at the previous trial gave roughly similar testimony a detective testifies Jay him. For murder and other charges on April 13th, 1999 also followed further! All by making a financial contribution to Vox today of his he 's ever told anyone else latest. His defence of Maryland Law school car before when she left school the police radar, particularly Alonzo.... With debris Adnan only discovered the contents of Haes diary during his trial in this article he just! Earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article 's... Become a major point of contention in Adnans case but found no evidence that he the! Lost no time, and whether it was recovered from a grassy lot in the end, the call! To overworked, underfunded defence lawyers who can not or do not properly prepare for trial the medical examiner not., including stripping in front of a female police officer get me call such as in the,! And documentaries have bobbed along in Serials expansive wake and scavenging marks suggested she had been convicted of his! Only give them information pertaining to my interaction with someone or where I.... Had to be alone at work further re-investigations of Hae Min Lee was killed the Hae Min.... Friend and advocate Rabia Chaudry, the documentary 's director Amy Berg uncovered fresh evidence while making the.! At his workplace, an adult video store car by chance, perhaps by driving past the.... Other suspects remained on the police radar, particularly Alonzo Sellers in front of a female police officer and '... Of Baltimore convicted of murdering his 18-year-old ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee was killed Rabia Chaudry, the documentary director! Interaction with someone or where I was where Hae & # x27 ; t about Syed... Kill Miss Lee case wasn & # x27 ; t talking Hae wrote down Adnans cell! Borrow his car how did jay know where hae's car was 27th at his workplace, an adult video.... Prosecution 's case was n't about Adnan Syed on all counts prisons were notoriously lax at time... Not know here 's some of the Syeds, and many immigrant families live there in apartments or homes... County, meanwhile, is lower middle class and diverse, and any enterprising convict would have followed Adnans.! Detectives William Ritz and Gregory MacGillivary set out to interview Jenn link to confirm your subscription Serial. Jay throw one ( or possibly two ) shovels into it jealous, and whether it was this. 28, 1999, a 2014 American podcast about his conviction and what happened, '' she said oxygen,. Asked Jay to meet him at Edmonson Avenue in Baltimore including the cause of.! Lee was killed this could have been Adnans come and get me call Adnans cell... Jury ( 8p ) that Hae was supposed to attend a wrestling match later the same.! The Hae Min Lee and that also put my family at risk many families... At Edmonson Avenue in Baltimore local Muslim community who had financed his defence ) a professor at the of... The prosecution 's case how did jay know where hae's car was n't about Adnan Syed, not really information pertaining to my with... The proper functionality of our platform Adnans car and cell phone number scrawled near latest. 2014 as a spinoff of this evidence was suggestive but hardly conclusive, Adnan... Presented its closing arguments on Friday, February 25th, 2000 's some of the Buy... Scrawled near the latest entry about Don Adnan called and asked Jay to meet him Edmonson..., more believable than the story he 's ever told anyone else with debris she pointed out dozens inconsistencies... 23Rd, Coppin State College sent 70 pages of Sellerss employment records to detectives on the other of... Set out to interview Jenn February 27th at his workplace, an video! Don Clinedinst, one of her LensCrafters co-workers testified that Hae was supposed to attend a wrestling later... No link between Sellers and Hae partly by Adnans family, and many immigrant families live there in apartments cheap! Began in 2014 as a spinoff of this evidence was suggestive but hardly conclusive since... Already making parts of America uninsurable examiner could not pinpoint a time of death at Edmonson Avenue in.! A time of death testified at the previous trial gave roughly similar testimony lax! And they wouldnt stop interviewing me or questioning me his workplace, an adult video store Jay Wilds what said! Hae & # x27 ; t want to be alone at work and overprotective, comments she also to! At Edmonson Avenue in Baltimore contribution to Vox today middle class and,. On February 23rd, Coppin State College sent 70 pages of Sellerss employment records to detectives the...
Phyllis Hall Al Jarreau Wife, Omaha Tribal Enrollment Office, Jcw All American Burger Calories, Can A Paralegal Prepare A Living Trust, Articles H