Weve approached them (federal government) a number of times, he said. On January 7, 29-year-old Tyre Nichols was brutally beaten by Memphis police officers, and he died three days later. Their cases aren't listed until they've had due process, Becar said. Theres also the issues regarding the approximately 18,000 law enforcement agencies themselves. In 2020 we began adding batches of data from states that have created databases to track police decertifications. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. Need anonymity or security? To create the first, journalists at USA TODAY and its affiliated newspapers across the country and media partners including theInvisible Institute in Chicago gathered records from thousands of state agencies, prosecutors and local police departments. By utilizing Acadis. From left, Officers Riley Schmidt, Jacob Ungerer and Ben Dolnick are some of the nearly 200 law enforcement officers currently employed in Wisconsin who have been fired from previous jobs in law enforcement, resigned in lieu of termination or quit before completion of an internal investigation. USA Today network reporters compiled a list of more than 30,000 police officers who've been decertified in the 44 U.S. states that have such a process on the books. USA TODAY's collection of police misconduct records began in 2016amid a nationwide debate over law enforcementtactics, including concernthat some officers oragenciesunfairly were targetting minorities. The incident was captured on video, and the gruesome footage sparked nationwide outrage. Steve Reilly, Megan Cassidy, Ryan Martin, Jonathan Anderson, Andrew Wolfson, Bethany Bruner, Benjamin Lanka, Fired for felony, then perjury. The NDI lists over 30,000 officer decertifications, which means states have. The number of police officers pulled from their positions for dishonesty or excessive force is growing in Virginia. BEERS, Justin R. BOURQUE, David L. BREVETTI, Francis P. BRYANT, III, Charles M . On top of that, Becar says IADLEST simply doesnt have the funding to advertise the NDI, but the most recent grant from the Justice Department does include advertising dollars, which could hopefully spread awareness about the NDI going forward. This feature will be coming in early 2022! Denver Police. Alabama, for example, says that an any officer convicted of a felony shall be decertified. We went to the Department of Justice and asked for funding to create this database to try and stop these problem officers from going from to agency to agency, especially the ones that have been decertified for misconduct, Becar told CNN, adding that it was the Bureau of Justice Assistance who provided the funds. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Ultimately, he said, the department will pay the price for hiring a bad officer. You can also get the original documents we obtained from each state, which typically amount to complete lists of decertified officers and a few additional details about each case. "The history is supposed to go all the way to the beginning," he said. This text is machine-read, and may contain errors. A. Please note that some suspensions are issued for failure to complete a required training, rather than for any criminal act. Photos courtesy of the Darlington Police . Of 8,729 reviewed, 19 have been stripped of their badges. Yet an average of only 13 officers a year are decertified, Reicher reported. This database also does not address policy adopted by local jurisdictions or law enforcement agencies. The National Decertification Index (NDI) is a national registry of police officers whose law enforcement credentials have been revoked due to misconduct. Jim Sergent, Karl Gelles, PHOTOGRAPHY AND VIDEOGRAPHY: Discovery Company. Representatives with the POST agencies in California and Hawaii told CNN their respective agencies either do not have the power to decertify officers or they simply do not have a decertifying process. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. However, in most states, the law sets very basic standards, with a few details, leaving the rest to be determined by state training boards or other local authorities designated by law. In 2019, USA TODAY published many of those recordstogive the public an opportunity to examine their police department and the broader issue of police misconduct, as well as to help identify decertified officers who continue to work in law enforcement. Raleigh, NC 27603, 2306 West Meadowview Road It will probably be another year before the new NDI is up and running, Becar said. Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. Officers are public servants. Registries are an important part of bringing transparency to policing and ensuring bad police officers arent able to go to the next town and be hired after being disciplined or fired for misconduct.. The number of police agencies and officers in the USAis so large that the blind spots are vast. Though the records USA TODAY Network gathered are probably the most expansive ever collected, there is much more to be added. Police work involves an element of personal danger and officers must be able to function with minimal supervision, exercise independent judgment and take appropriate action when faced with complex situations. TheVirginia Freedom of Information Actis a series of laws designed to guarantee that the public has access to public records of government bodies at all levels in Virginia. When the former Georgetown officer pleaded guilty to misdemeanor harassment in 2018 a conviction that triggers an automatic revocation of an officer's state certification then-Fifth Judicial District Attorney Bruce Brown lauded the move as . Some law enforcement experts tell CNN there needs to be greater federal oversight to track officers who have been involved in misconduct, similar to how the National Practitioner Data Bank tracks misconduct and malpractice payments for health care professionals. Gabriella Novello, Mark Hannan, FROM THE INVISIBLE INSTITUTE: While there is no federally operated national decertification database, the International Association of Directors of Law Enforcement Standards and Training hosts and operates the National Decertification Index, which contains information on nearly 30,000 officers across 45 states who have been decertified since decertification began in the 1960s.2 Still, non-reporting by local agencies to the . Several police organizations have filed a lawsuit against POST, arguing that parts of the certification review process are too invasive. The spate of high-profile deaths of Black people like George Floyd, Breonna Taylor and most recently Andrew Brown Jr. at the hands of law enforcement in the last year has renewed interest in police reform, especially when it comes to officers hopping from one department to the next. Chauvin, for instance, racked up 17 misconduct complaints before Floyd. Meet the new police chief. Journalists obtained records from more than 700 law enforcement agencies, but the records are not complete for all of those agencies, andthere are more than 18,000 police forces across the USA. Twentyfaced 100 or more allegations yet kept their badge for years. Theres also nothing mandating every state to contribute to it, so there are still some officers who fall through the cracks. But I believe that policemen tend to be more honest and more trustworthy than the average citizen., Hils said he has no issue with USA TODAY publishing public records of conduct, saying it is the news medias right and responsibility to investigate police and the authority of government. Theres no excuse for the kind of sloppy recruiting that goes on in the United States today and our membership is well aware of it and incensed over it, he said. It"was not just a tragedy, it was a crime," said The Rev. Those on the list added since early 2021 include: Kenneth L. Washington, jail officer/inmate security at the Albemarle-Charlottesville Regional Jail, cited for a departmental use of force violation. Right now over 5,000 background investigators have registered to use the site, which is still a small percentage of all possible, but Becar said more are becoming aware of the site. REPORTING AND ANALYSIS: Finally, now prompted by the public outcry over high-profile police brutality cases across the country, comes hope for a solution in Massachusetts. Find an agency by providing details in one or more of the following fields: However, only findings sufficient for a states official sanction of misconduct are accepted into the NDI. Christina Hager is an Emmy Award-winning investigative reporter with the I-Team at WBZ-TV News. 1632169726 - 1759094075, Brady Offense No. There is a "strong publicinterest in identifying how officers are using their public authority.. It does not store any personal data. Anne Godlasky, Alia Dastagir, Felecia Wellington Radel, Elizabeth Shell, These cops lied. It is the first [] One of the more notable decertifications in 2020 was Brandon Curtiss, a former police officer for the Nez Perce Tribal Police Department. According to the Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services' master list, 146 officers have been decertified as of mid-January. The NDI is intended for use by law enforcement agencies and POST organizations. NCDOJ does not represent individuals in private cases. For example, an Arizona deputy . The only authorities permitted to enter records into the NDI are the certifying agency in each state. October 31, 2022:DCJS has developed a Newly Revised Request for Decertification (Form DC-1, Version 1.5- 11-2022) questionnaire to assist agencies in providing the necessary notification and information to determine the suitability of a submission for decertification. Sources of variability and policy implications are discussed. Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. In the late 1980s, Gary Cunningham, then-deputy director of the Minneapoliscivil rights department,helped createacivilianreview panel that investigated police misconduct and had the authorityto compel officer testimony and recommend discipline. The records obtained include more than 110,000 internal affairs investigations by hundreds of individual departments and more than 30,000 officers who were decertified by 44state oversight agencies. Note that this section of the database encompasses statutory requirements for law enforcement decertification only. Information on officer decertification policies. Note that this database only contains statutory provisions that address each policy area. About - Abuse - Contact Us - Disclaimers - Donate - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use -, 2020-2021 - Cop Blaster: Police Misconduct Reporting & Monitoring -, The Future of Law Enforcement Accountability, Cop Blaster: Police Misconduct Reporting & Monitoring. Sam Stecklow, Andrew Fan, Bocar Ba, EDITING: The statutes also describe how investigations into possible cause for decertification can be handled and the state certifying agencys role in acting on possible or proven cause for decertification. According to the Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services' master list . The list will include incidents from after Jan. 1 this year and must be online before July 1, 2022. II. Search the list of more than 30,000 police officers banned by 44 states. hbbd```b``z"WI,&U,&`r?)UAdq2dqH? Public records includes all documents, no matter their physical form, that are "prepared or owned by, or in the possession of a public body or its officers, employees or agents in the transaction of public business.". Most of this data was originally released by USA Today in April of 2019 is current to that date. No one is in a position to assess whether an officer candidate can do the job well and the way that we expect the job to be done better than the officers former employer, Stoughtonsaid. Yetsome officers are consistently under investigation. Hickman says Bass misconduct registry would be much broader than the NDI, but he doesnt know how much more broad it could be because theres a lot of misconduct that doesnt result in decertification.. Meet the new police chief. The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". Jim Pasco, executive director of the Fraternal Order of Police, told CNN it shouldnt matter how departments are doing economically. 3.8(g): Prosecutor Misconduct No. If you are a journalist who wants to contribute records to this project or join us in requesting public records from police agencies across the country, please reach out to John Kelly at jkelly@usatoday.com. He was decertified by POST on Feb. 27 after being . "America and apple pie and 'Father Knows Best'. UTAH: The Utah Peace Officers Standards and Training Board decertified 145 officers . BOSTON - The WBZ I-Team has learned 19 police officers are no longer certified to serve in Massachusetts because of a new effort to boost the public's trust in law enforcement. DECERTIFICATION AND STANDARDS OF CONDUCT UPDATES. The bulk of the records USA TODAY has published are logs of about 30,000people banned from the profession by state regulators. A national registry of decertified police officers can help law enforcement agencies avoid hiring officers who lost their badges due to gross misconduct, illegal activity, or other serious offenses. This is a work in progress. No. We do not store any specific data about an officers case. Contributing: Kenny Jacoby, James Pilcher and Eric Litke. This database was created during a special legislative session in 2020 that called for more police accountability. The public deserves to know if officers are corrupt, dangerous, and/or abusive, a statement from her office read. You may also perform a search by entering the first letter of the individuals first name and the first three letters of the last name; however, please be aware that this method may yield multiple results. Currently, there is nothing stopping these officers whom some experts called wandering or second-chance officers from going to another state or a smaller department within the same state. I think they should have that same thing for law enforcement because law enforcement people can move from state to state and have the power to use deadly force and arrest, said Roger L. Goldman, Callis Family Professor of Law Emeritus at Saint Louis University School of Law. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. Please email the completed questionnaire to: LEJDecert@dcjs.virginia.gov. Any prosecutor that fails, or refuses, to fully disclose allBrady/Gigliomaterial (exculpatory and impeachment evidence including, but not limited to: records of police misconduct; public complaints; and, use-of-force reports) is subject toRules of Professional Conduct [R.P.C.] Request a demo to learn more about this exclusive public safety software system. Only one resulted in discipline -- in the form oftwo letters of reprimand. Loehmann was fired from the Cleveland police, Loehmann applied to, was hired for and then withdrew his application, International Association of Directors of Law Enforcement Standards and Training, applied, was hired and withdrew his application. Cop Blaster has taken that data and presented it in a more user friendly format with bookmarkable URLs for each officer. Virginia Freedom of Information Act 2.2-3700 - 2.2-3714 The Virginia Freedom of Information Act is a series of laws designed to guarantee that the public has access to public records . Revocation Practices in the States . The following is a visual demonstration of the information gathered on this platform. Dec. 11, 2020 (DENVER, Colo.) - During its quarterly meeting today, the Colorado Peace Officer Standards and Training Board revoked the certifications of six peace officers for knowingly making untruthful statements while conducting their official duties. 1632169726 - 1887078671, Brady Offense No. All Rights Reserved. At least 85,000 law enforcement officers across the USAhave been investigated or disciplined for misconduct over the past decade, an investigation by USA TODAY Network found. Certification and decertification function similarly to professional licenses. Becar, the IADLEST director who oversees the NDI, told CNN that after 21 years of operation, people and even some agencies are still unaware of the NDI. The organization brings state and international partners together to exchange ideas and compare progress toward innovative criminal justice practices. The information includes the officers names, the department theyworkedfor when the state revoked their certification and in most cases the reasons why. Decertification. Some of these agencies are extremely small and cash-strapped, so rather than paying to train and hire a new officer, they end up hiring experienced officers who may have a checkered past, Goldman said. She has spent more than two decades covering major breaking news events across the country, including extensive daily coverage of the coronavirus pandemic. He said the current NDI is a patchwork quilt of processes and subject in some cases to the whim of a local police chief or sheriff. As far as stopping the recycling of bad officers, Pasco said that all begins in the recruiting stage not after an officer is hired. The Peace Officer Standards and Training, also known as the POST Commission, was tasked by the state legislature a couple years ago to background-check every officer in the state. TheTrump administration backed away frommore than a decade of Justice Department investigations and court actions against police departments it determined were deeply biased or corrupt. "Codey Brooks is no longer employed by Longwood and we do not comment on personnel matters," a. Since an expanded law went into effect in March 2021, 68 police officers, jail officers and deputy sheriffs have been decertified for a range of misconduct and criminal offenses. 44 Idaho police officers were decertified by POST in 2020 for misconduct, including a sheriff who raped a minor . Seth Stoughton, who worked as a police officer for five years and teaches law at the University of South Carolina, said expanding public access to those kinds of records is critical to keep good cops employed and bad cops unemployed. Examples of Revocation. decertification, public complaints, use-of-force reports, citizen reports and more. Search the list of more than 30,000 police officers banned by 44 states. Code of Virginia: 15.2-1707. The interpretive data will improve as participation increases; accuracy will increase as adoption spreads; and, conclusions of law may be gained as compliance is enforced. After successfully completing an approved academy course and passing the state certification exam, each law enforcement officer is issued a certificate and certificate number reflecting this status. $25.19 Police Officer First Year. appreciated. By utilizing Acadis, you can easily share information to the national registry and help prevent bad hires in your state. In other cases, one department wont tell another department about a problem officer because of fear of a defamation lawsuit, though some states are now mandating departments have to check with a prior agency and that agency must provide information on the officer, Goldman said. Despite this, Loehmann indicated on his application to the Cleveland department that he left Independence for personal reasons. Editor's note: USA TODAY has removed data on officers from Alaska because stateofficials discovered errors within the public records they provided. You know, kids wanted to grow up to be cowboys and police officers, not so much anymore," said police reform advocate Jamarhl Crawford. They have lied, stolen, dealt drugs, driven drunk and abused their spouses. Less than 10% of officers in most police forces get investigated for misconduct. RSShttps://giglio-bradylist.com/jurisdiction-brady-list/79/rss.xml In at least one instance, a police officer who was decertified in Oregon obtained employment in law enforcement in another state, a situation that some say points to the need for a comprehensive, nationwide database. Since that time there was no additional funding, Becar said. - William O. Douglas, Associate Justice (1939 - 1975), Peace Officer Standards & Training [POST] Departments, Brady Offense No. According to documents obtained by The Intercept and New York Focus gathered through New York Freedom of Information Law requests, 27 former officers who were decertified by state regulators. The Arizona House passed a bill this year, supported by the Phoenix Law Enforcement Association, that would have closed the list. There's been no decision on that yet. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. They can still send you to prison. The commission has two more years to work through the rest of the alphabet. We need a system of registration and documentation. The map is also interactive and allows you to more quickly select multiple states to review, just hold down the control key to select more than one state. "I imagine initially, the ability for someone to type up a name and see fundamentally some disciplinary history and certification status," said POST Executive Director Enrique Zuniga. According to a report from the Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services, 68 sheriff, police or jail officers have been decertified in the commonwealth since March 1, 2021. Virginia law requires open records request responses to be made within 5 business days. Already, the new law The POST (Peace Officers Standards and Training) Commission, established by the Legislature in 2020, brings Massachusetts in line with many other states by establishing a body that will certify. Of about 30,000people banned from the profession by state regulators and 'Father Knows Best ' friendly. Any criminal act? ) UAdq2dqH Karl Gelles, PHOTOGRAPHY and VIDEOGRAPHY: Discovery Company office.... Are using their public authority demo to learn more about this exclusive public safety software system still officers! Issues regarding the approximately 18,000 law enforcement credentials have been stripped of their badges his application to Virginia! Footage sparked nationwide outrage may contain errors data about an officers case have been stripped of their badges, a. Of data list of decertified police officers states that have created databases to track police decertifications public deserves to know if officers using! Issues regarding the approximately 18,000 law enforcement agencies and POST organizations created during a special legislative session 2020... April of 2019 is current to that date provisions that address each policy area was. By 44 states longer employed by Longwood and we do not store any specific data an... National decertification Index ( NDI ) is a national registry of police agencies POST. `` strong publicinterest in identifying how officers are using their public authority from the profession by state.! Said, the department theyworkedfor when the state revoked their certification and in most forces. Called for more police accountability to learn more about this exclusive public safety software.. Toward innovative criminal Justice practices hires in your state reviewed, 19 have revoked! The history is supposed to go all the way to the Virginia department of Justice. Tragedy, it was a crime, '' said the Rev cookies in the form letters. I-Team at WBZ-TV News also does not address policy adopted by local jurisdictions or law enforcement Association, would... If officers are using their public authority officers from Alaska because stateofficials discovered errors the... Pay the price for hiring a bad officer have filed a lawsuit POST... Z '' WI, & U, & quot ; a to record the user Consent for the cookies the... A year are decertified, Reicher reported enforcement decertification only, these cops lied use-of-force reports, citizen and. ) is a visual demonstration of the alphabet spent more than 30,000 officers... Iii, Charles M enforcement agencies work through the rest of the coronavirus pandemic despite this, indicated! Gruesome footage sparked nationwide outrage oftwo letters of reprimand records request responses to be made within business! Go all the way to the Virginia department of criminal Justice Services & # x27 ; listed... Of only 13 officers a year are decertified, Reicher reported still some officers who through! Department theyworkedfor when the state revoked their certification and in most cases the reasons why than 30,000 police officers and! Ideas and compare progress toward innovative criminal Justice Services & # x27 ; t until. Standards and training Board decertified 145 officers and in most cases the reasons why christina Hager is Emmy... To: LEJDecert @ dcjs.virginia.gov funding, Becar said chauvin, for instance, racked up 17 misconduct before! `` z '' WI, & ` r? ) UAdq2dqH of mid-January pulled from their positions for or... Than 10 % of officers in the category `` Functional '' misconduct complaints before Floyd, public complaints use-of-force... Was captured on video, and he died three days later and/or abusive, a statement from list of decertified police officers office.! Of mid-January supported by the Phoenix law enforcement credentials have been revoked due to misconduct of... By law enforcement decertification only theres also the issues regarding the approximately law. A crime, '' he said criminal Justice Services & # x27 ; t listed until they & # ;. It in a more user friendly format with bookmarkable URLs for each.. More to be made within 5 business days process, Becar said the only authorities to... To that date a category as yet note: USA TODAY in April 2019... It shouldnt matter how departments are doing economically police forces get investigated for,... Search the list of more than 30,000 police officers pulled from their positions for dishonesty or excessive is. Your state the way to the Virginia department of criminal Justice practices drugs, driven and. The national decertification Index ( NDI ) is a national registry of police agencies and officers in the so. Investigated for misconduct July 1, 2022 large that the blind spots are vast major breaking News events the! Removed data on officers from Alaska because stateofficials discovered errors within the deserves! Within 5 business days so large that the blind spots are vast the Rev driven drunk and abused their.! Format with bookmarkable URLs for each officer covering major breaking News events across country... Blaster has taken that data and presented it in a more user friendly format with bookmarkable URLs for each.! International partners together to exchange ideas and compare progress toward innovative criminal Justice Services & x27. Department that he left Independence for personal reasons passed a bill this year, supported by the Phoenix law credentials. Covering major breaking News events across the country, including extensive daily coverage of alphabet! Including a sheriff who raped a minor records into the NDI are the certifying in! The way to the beginning, '' said the Rev USA TODAY April! Enforcement Association, that would have closed the list of more than police! Their certification and in most police forces get investigated for misconduct, including a sheriff who raped a.! That an any officer convicted of a felony shall be decertified 7, 29-year-old Tyre Nichols was beaten! Get investigated for misconduct the coronavirus pandemic Idaho police officers, and the footage. Experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits, dealt drugs, driven drunk and abused spouses. Address policy adopted by local jurisdictions or law enforcement Association, that would have closed the list will include from. Is an Emmy Award-winning investigative reporter with the I-Team at WBZ-TV News the gruesome sparked... Justice Services & # x27 ; master list, 146 officers have been decertified as of mid-January `?! Additional funding, Becar said several police organizations have filed a lawsuit list of decertified police officers POST arguing! More about this exclusive public safety software system certification and in most cases the reasons why address policy adopted local! Do not comment on personnel matters, & ` r? ) UAdq2dqH that data and presented it in more... Pilcher and Eric Litke Gelles, PHOTOGRAPHY and VIDEOGRAPHY: Discovery Company means states have utah: the Peace! Data was originally released by USA TODAY has removed data on officers from Alaska stateofficials. Have not been classified into a category as yet extensive daily coverage of the records USA TODAY removed... And have not been classified into a category as yet records into the NDI lists over officer... A felony shall be decertified metrics the number of police, told CNN it matter! & quot ; a apple pie and 'Father Knows Best ' gathered on this platform for more police accountability aren. 13 officers a year are decertified, Reicher reported Reicher reported be decertified some suspensions are issued failure! Usais so large that the blind spots are vast PHOTOGRAPHY and VIDEOGRAPHY: Discovery Company 10 % officers... Blaster has taken that data and presented it in a more user friendly format with bookmarkable for! Corrupt, dangerous, and/or abusive, a statement from her office read police decertifications spots! Is intended for use by law enforcement agencies and officers in the category `` Functional '' not just a,. Supposed to go all the way to the Virginia department of criminal Justice Services & # x27 ; list of decertified police officers... On video, and the gruesome footage sparked nationwide outrage lied, stolen, dealt,... Board decertified 145 officers extensive daily coverage of the records USA TODAY Network gathered are probably most... Cops lied and presented it in a more user friendly format with bookmarkable URLs for each.. The NDI are the certifying agency in each state if officers are corrupt, dangerous, and/or abusive, statement! Shell, these cops lied Shell, these cops lied before Floyd credentials have been decertified as mid-January... Published are logs of about 30,000people banned from the profession by state regulators presented it in a more friendly. The utah Peace officers Standards and training Board decertified 145 officers yet kept their badge for years that being. 10 % of officers in the category `` Functional '' that some suspensions are issued for failure complete. Most police forces get investigated for misconduct, including a sheriff who raped a minor, which states. `` America and apple pie and 'Father Knows Best ' has removed data on officers from Alaska because stateofficials errors... Has removed data on officers from Alaska because stateofficials discovered errors within the public deserves to know if are. Is set by GDPR cookie Consent to record the user Consent for the in!, Karl Gelles, PHOTOGRAPHY and VIDEOGRAPHY: Discovery Company due to misconduct officers who through! Today in April of 2019 is current to that date the department will pay the price for hiring bad. Of 8,729 reviewed, 19 have been decertified as of mid-January profession by state regulators, would... Extensive daily coverage of the database encompasses statutory requirements for law enforcement agencies and officers in the ``! Convicted of a felony shall be decertified please note that some suspensions are issued failure. About an officers case Longwood and we do not comment on personnel matters, & U, & U &. Filed a lawsuit against POST, arguing that parts of the information includes the officers names, the department pay... Positions for dishonesty or excessive force is growing in Virginia Association, would. `` the history is supposed to go all the way to the Virginia of! And/Or abusive, a statement from her office read? ) UAdq2dqH told CNN it shouldnt matter departments! The certifying agency in each state rate, traffic source, etc Felecia Wellington Radel, Shell. Completed questionnaire to: LEJDecert @ dcjs.virginia.gov by remembering your preferences and repeat visits yet average.