The adjustable grip size would be a benefit if you had smaller hands or maybe average hands with short, stubby fingers. This Product can expose you to chemicals including lead, which is known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. Thats why I bought the Gen 4 as my second Glock. This part is compatible with the ejector used in the Glock 19 Gen 3 pistol and could be changed. I get Glock Knuckle from both of them. Cominolli safety for glocks is a alternative, it puts a external safety on. in length. Its either going to break right away or last for a very long time. Much more controllable, easier to shoot, etc. It was my winter carry gun in NC, but Im now a FL resident and its just too big a lump to conceal OWB under just a polo or t-shirt. I do carry a full size 1911 during the cooler months but the G36 and the G26 are better for me during the warmer months. The age of wood and steel is far from over, but the age of plastic has certainly been in full swing for some time now and lots of gun owners have grown to like (or at least appreciate) polymer pistols. But this is not that. So until laws change, I think Glock will continue to produce them. 41 Replies to "Glock Gen 3 vs Gen 4" William T.Farrow says: September 10, 2017 at 04:49 . Glock did change the design of the ejector in the Glock 19 4th Generation handgun. Hornady American Gunner 185gr JHP-848fps, 3.0 Expand your knowledge and make educated decisions to Another feature that the Glock Gen 3 guns lack is the modular backstraps. And the G36 has the characteristic GLOCK trigger pull thats frequently described as mushy. Discussions on any and all topics are welcome even with different opinions. The Glock 19 Gen 4 upgrades are subtle, yet leap out at the same time. The one really odd thing I found was the thinner frame. I took the trigger down to 2.5 lbs. Comparing them, the gen 3 SF frame seems a bit fatter left-to-right, almost as if the handle is more oval. I really dont care for the way the grip feels to me on the 19 & 23. I think everyone should be putting 3 mags with a new gun, its just a courteous thing to do. I liked it enough to pick up a G30SF frame and make my own FrankenGlock G30s, which also did brief carry duty. Capacity: 6+1 Rounds Like virtually all GLOCK pistols, its dependable and will go bang when needed. While completely and utterly late to the single-stack subcompact 9mm party, it still became one of their most popular pistols to date. Youre quite the dick. Which is better? Do not install the reduced weight striker spring. You will feel the same 5.5-pound semi-double action trigger pull on both the Glock 19 Gen 3 and the Glock 19 Gen 4. The extra magazine is the obvious nice touch by Glock. My Gen 4 broke after exactly 500 rounds. The Gen 4 is the first of the Glock 19 Generations to use a larger, dual-recoil spring guide rod. The new mag release button is not only larger, but it extends farther back to allow for much faster, easier mag changes. so get this amazing Red Puffer Vest which is a favorite of all girls and it is the most-rated and most selling outfit in our store, shop now because the stock is limited. In looking at the Glock 19 Gen 3 vs Gen 4 some parts that were changed stand alone and cannot be interchanged. Its the mid sized gun and a great place to start. Both pistols use 9mm ammo and have the same standard magazine capacity of 15 rounds. Its going to come down to personal choice and what you can find. . Not ready to part after 12 years. Shoot both if possible. His varied interests and hobbies include camping, fishing, hunting, and spending time at the gun range as often as possible. New Grips, new night sights and a +1 replacement to the mags. I worked for an armored car company for almost 7 years mostly in the LA area of California. Its now my mission and purpose in life. No more problems since. The next item to discuss in the Glock Gen 3 vs Gen 4 ordeal is the frame. And who doesn't like to change their guns up just a bit to fit their own style? In the end, its a personal choice. My other gripe is my pinky get pinched between the bottom of the grip and the mag. Then there's the elephant in the room, price. The Gen 4 measures 7.95 in. The Gen 4 functions the same as the Gen 3 even when it comes to assembly and disassembly. One large point of contention shooters had with the Glock 19 Generation 3 was the grips being too large for smaller hands. I carry IWB or OWB with the holster between the belt and trouser band. Now have a Shield 2.0 45, like it better. However, a lot of Gen 4 guns will be in and out of police trade-in inventory at various dealers, shops and so forth on the used market. At its core, the Glock is a Spartan, all business handgun that is a pleasure to carry and shoot. I find the G36 easier to manage and am able to shoot it better so it is my carry gun. Both barrels measure 4.48 in. Id be surprised if they arent already hard at work on just that. This is a different pistol with the magazine extension. However, the reverse is not true. Heck no. Detailed review on comparison between Glock Gen 3 and Glock Gen 4 WhattheFuss? Same Day Shipping when order is placed before 1PM EST, SAME DAY SHIPPING WHEN ORDER IS PLACED BEFORE 1PM EST. What did you have to do to get your trigger weight that far down? SIG SAUER 185gr V-Crown JHP925fps, 2.25 And no I did not use the laser to qualify. Most lie within the fire control mechanism. It was accurate, for one shot but followups were slow and sometimes required readjusting my grip. Unless you're a police officer, you can't buy one! It's a small gun, with its overall length at 6.97 inches, and the slide is nearly the same length as the entire gun at 6.77 inches. It is possible to install the connector for a Glock 19 Gen 4 into a Gen 3. The 36 is reliable and accurate enough for self defense. I dont know what Gaston was thinking. Sounds like the dudes that bitch so much about it need to hit the weight room to improve their pathetic forearms. Now its my back up gun. Compared to Gen 3 models, not including RTF versions, Gen 4 grips have a more aggressive texturing. In order to find out when your particular gun was made, you had to do a search on its serial number. So buy the one you want and enjoy it. Have yet to fire stout ammo but gun seems very good for overall weight and size. I just didnt want to rebuild the entire thing, but will sooner or later. Barrel Length: 3.75 I would gladly let him know about this. There is also the reversible magazine catch for lefties, which is a plus. I think that indentation on the bottom back of the trigger guard doesnt help either. Glock 19 Gen 3 and Gen 4 Dimension: Overall Length: Gen 3: 7.36-inch Gen 4: 7.28-inch Slide Length: 6.85-inch Overall Width: 1.26-inch Slide Width: 1-inch Height (including magazine): 5.04-inch Line of Sight (Polymer): 6.02-inch Trigger Distance: Gen 3: 2.80-inch Gen 4: 2.76-inch Glock Gen 3 Vs Gen 4: Similarities Trigger Pull Weight Safety Surprisingly accurate and manageable my first time at the range. Caliber: .45 ACP Your middle finger getting rubbed raw is another story. The first difference between Glock 19 Gen 3 and Gen 4 that many sees are the grips. Overall Length: 7 Thats really not necessary. i have been shooting with Glocks since 1992 and have had more than my fair share of models. Its a little lighter and a little smoother. Never a bad idea to sharpen the skills with good training. All Rights Reserved. Its a little bit of pain but worth the $100 if they have the one you want. all have extensions. Another PoS Tupperware for glocktards to drool over. The Glock Gen-5 version is better for those who are more comfortable with a simple, bare-to-the-bone trigger. The flattened pancake look of the gun and the off-putting differences in surface texture wont turn any heads. Aside from the words stamped on its side, take a look at the business end of the muzzle. Apparently my G36 is a different gun cleverly disguised as a G36. If youre whining about recoil, perhaps a .45 of any brand is not for you. My 7th Glock! Is this a come-on or a good service by Glock. I love my Glock 36 and am pleased with it in every aspect. I also like my Glock 26 which I bought in 1996. Velocity is the average of ten shots and accuracy is the average of three, five-shot groups at 15 yards. Also, is there a trigger upgrade, spring upgrade available? He said if I couldnt get it done with 7 rds I probably couldnt do it at all. Install a 3.5 lb. Apologies, southpaws. Some just shoot what they brought. Just Bidded on one, might win might not I hope I win really looking forward to getting a G36. Now I want to bring that experience and my joy of teaching to others. While the Glock was not the first polymer framed handgun, it was the first to be marketed in large numbers and adopted by not only the shooting public but the military and law enforcement. As a result, GLOCK eventually released the G21 with the American market in mind. I bought my Glock 36 in 2001(DTH 194). Shootability? Since then they have steadily grown stronger, firmly establishing their reputation as a durable, reliable weapon. Thanks for the info Ben. The Complete Guide to Glock Generations [2022], A Guide To The Glock Slimline Pistols: The Glock 43X and Glock 48. The G36 I used for this review came equipped from the factory with Trijicon night sights. Glock makes some minor revisions every so often to their basic design, leading to a new "generation" about every 10 years or so. Umarex Glock 17 Gen3 vs Gen4. Im just a civilian so I hope and pray that I will never be in a self defense situation where I need more than 1 mag.Most self defense situations Ive seen or heard about were pretty close quarters, not clear across the room(although I see a lot of that in the movies). What you want to do with the gun and what size your hands are are very important to the process. I completely disagree with bad ergonomic ratings. I can see that you really have great knowledge in terms of guns. The accuracy is typical of glock (Its good) As accurate as any of my other Glock pistols. The slide serrations were changed to fish scales and the texturing was changed, with stipling rather than a rough texture on the sides and checkering on the front and back of the grip. I have no idea how you can carry the pistol to get slide bite. For more information go towww.p65Warnings.ca.gov, Este producto puede exponerle aqumicosincluyendo plomo, que es conocido por el Estado de California come causante de cncer y defectos de nacimiento u otros daos reproductivos. It provides a positive hold and control of the weapon in less than perfect conditions. You have entered an incorrect email address! Have fun with it. All in the black 4-5 inch circle. The frame designed for the Glock 19 4th Generation handgun is smaller than that of the Glock 19 Gen 3. No complaints overall. EFK Spring with the buffered/dual action recoil relief per the EFK website shows 40% reduction of recoil which sounds good, especially with the snappy .40 S&W. The general idea behind it is still sound, but is at this point the G36 is significantly outclassed by other .45 ACP pistols in the same genre. Thanks Daric! The bangs just stop a lot sooner. Fairly accurate, has never jammed on me and is easy to conceal. I think I would prefer the G23 over the G19. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. While its not necessarily the most compact .45 out there, the GLOCK 36 is a reliable and sturdy gun for daily CCW use. If you love to wear vests? I figured out the frame was thinner when I was working on Massad Ayoobs crush grip. Thats Awesome Earl! The next visible difference between Glock 19 Gen 3 and Gen 4 is its slide. Capacity? Stumbled across this old G36 review just a day after pulling out one of my two old G36s from the safe and heading to the range with it. I find the grip to be comfortable while I have large hands the grips fits me fine. I fired the G36 over my Oehler 35P chronograph at a distance of five feet from the muzzle. In knowing which generation of Glock you have you can narrow down when it was made or at least when Glock started making them. If you see some that look a little different its because the guns being made in America and the ones being made in Austria have a finish that looks a little different. However, when you factor in the perks that may apply to your situation just how much is that difference in price really? The trigger bar deactivates the firing pin safety once the trigger is pulled. Buy a wolf gunsprings Glock competition trigger pack ($10) and install 2 of the 3 springs. Sometimes I forget I have it on me. The Glock phenomenon came to life in the early eighties. I can respect that, but the gun we are left with is left wanting in todays concealed carry market. Ive owned numerous G 9mms over the years and they are all gone. Thanks for your opinions and commentary. But there will always be parts for the Gen 3 and I think the guns will be made for a long time. (And black slidelike how black slides came out the week after I bought by 48). The Gen 3 guns, much like the first two generations, are workhorse pistols. It to is homely but it can cook. Just got the G29 10mm and was wanting a nother carry with a little less recoil. Despite a single stack magazines, the flat, wide grip and narrow profile make the gun feel akin to a 24 in the hand and it torques under recoil as a result. Its been over 10 years since I bought my 1st gen Glock G36 Slimline because at the time it was the smallest .45ACP I could find. The problems are from limp-dicking it. That will tell you which to get. Accuracy * * Im not the strongest person, but not a wimp either, but I can actually squeeze hard enough to make the grip flex on the Gen 4. Even if you get a used gun, it's still a Glock. for me the G19 Gen3 is the best i have ever owned or shot. As are you. The heavier spring is designed specifically to not only manage recoil but to minimize abuse to the frame of the gun. This is a welcome upgrade to the Glock 19 Generation 3 for those southpaws out there. Very thorough information! Its far bulkier than it needs to be and isnt kind on the eyes. It does not make a difference in my ability to conceal it. The pinky getting pinched is the easiest issue, that will be solved with the bigger gun. difference at? Not to start caliber wars, but I would just as soonmhave 40 with a stubby barrel as a 45 with a stubby barrel. The Gen 4 I can just squeeze the entire grip with a shooting grip and feel it flex. I have a Glock 36 that was worked for grip size and texture. I was expecting a bit more from the G36, but I wasnt to be rewarded the way I had hoped. Another blessing of this pistol is that it has a plethora of aftermarket accessories available for it (think aftermarket trigger and night sights). I would not keep it without the +1 extensions it makes that much of a difference. Have a G36. I trained to rotate the gun slightly in my hand when hitting the mag release, and imagining Im holding a tea cup with pinky out when bringing the new mag up and in. I love this gun and would highly recommend it to anyone. Mine gave me blood blisters every time I speed mag changes. Pistol Fighting Dynamics Course San Antonio, Pistol Fighting Dynamics Course North Texas. .easier to wrap my hand around the smaller diameter grip. 36. I shoot a whole lot, obviously. Now the guns are running well. I have never given a gun a one star rating in ergonomics before, but this one takes it. Ergonomics * When looking at the forward edge of the grip you will notice the same finger grooves on both models. Glock set the standard and most other striker fired guns are following glock example. This system is nothing new to Glock as they have used it in their sub-compact pistols for years. Why isnt it like my G19, a longer, full, grip with a normal basepad ? Overall * * * Also, you can't overlook the legendary Glock reliability. Even if you somehow got the Gen 3 slide onto the frame of the newer Gen 4 gun, there's no way the recoil spring guide rod would ever fit through. . Right now, you can buy several generations of Glock pistol at one, but since there are only a couple of Gen 5 guns, you're pretty much confined to Glock Gen 3 vs Glock Gen 4. Fits nicely IWB with just a t-shirt. My favorite is the Glock 19. Therein lies some of the problems that the Gen 4 9mms had. By changing the overall size of the grip you change the length of pull of the trigger. Nothing is changed internally or really all that substantially; the gun is pretty much the same except for some surface changes. Glocks too proud of their tupperware anyway. Yes its uglyits a Glock, Get Pearce grip extension to add +1 capacity, Aftermarket items are the key. Have carried my G36 for 10+ years with no issues Fits my hand well, recoil quite manageable for a subcompact, accurate, and have never had a reliability issue after 1,000 rounds of FMJ or JHP from the major brand ammos I did get a trigger job done and added night sights. There a lot of spring kits and trigger kits on the market. A 1911 of similar size holds at least another round while being far more comfortable in the hand. I learned that from Hickok45 way back and it made me a FAR better shooter and I could care less about a longer grip nowadays. JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser. The smaller trigger housing fits in the smaller Glock 19 4th Generation frame. First of all I like guns not brands (same for cars). It is also thinner in the grip than the G19/23 and slab sided, so it carries very comfortably in a thin suede IWB holster, and the beveled muzzle also makes holstering easy. I was a reserve for 10 years with 2 years of active duty and 1 tour in Iraq in 2003. GLOCK safety, reliability, and simple operation, all at an affordable price. I just bought my 1st Glock 26 Gen 3. Function dictates form here. Not long after, Umarex released the Glock 19 non-blowback followed by the Glock 17 Gen 3. I use to carry a Dan Wesson .357 Magnum in service for a PD. Why shouldn't our handguns be offered the same way? And Ive shot a LOT of them. I have put just over 800 rounds through the Gen4 and while there is nothing wrong with it in anyway, I keep coming back to the Gen3. just to guys with 2 diameter forearms. He didn't fix what wasn't broken. The different back straps should only matter if the Gen 3 doesnt fit you hand. I dont have a ton of dollars to buy what I really want so I buy what I need. I plan to get another extension making my carry total of 21 rounds with two mag changes. But what I really want is a 48 style in 45acp.